Oxify vs P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts — Which Should You Install?
P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts (by Pareto) is one of the most established quantity break apps on the Shopify App Store, with around 250 reviews at 4.9 stars. Oxify Quantity Breaks & BYOB is a newer app with a 4.9-star rating from 8 reviews — and it is completely free. Both carry the Built for Shopify badge. Here is an honest head-to-head so you can pick the right one.
Built for Shopify · 4.9 ★ rating · 100% free — no paid plans · 1-click install
- Pricing & free plans
- Offer limits
- Quantity breaks
- BOGO & bundles
- B2B & wholesale
- Reviews & track record
~250 reviews at 4.9 stars, plus deeper B2B, wholesale and upsell tooling.
$0/month for the whole app — unlimited offers, BOGO and bundles included.
Quick answer
The decision comes down to offer count and budget. Both apps do quantity breaks well and both are Built for Shopify certified.
- Oxify is free — $0/month, unlimited offers, with BOGO, mix & match, Build Your Own Box and free gifts all included at no cost.
- P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts has a free plan capped at 1 active offer. Paid plans run $14.99 (5 offers), $29.99 (unlimited + BOGO/bundles) and $59.99/month.
- P: leads on track record — roughly 250 reviews vs Oxify's 8 — and on B2B/wholesale pricing, post-purchase and checkout upsells, and AI translation.
- Pick Oxify if you want every offer type across many products at zero cost. Pick P: if you need its B2B or upsell features, or you want a longer review history.
Oxify vs P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts, feature by feature
| Oxify Quantity Breaks & BYOB | P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts | |
|---|---|---|
| Developer | Oxify | Pareto |
| Rating | 4.9 / 5 | 4.9 / 5 |
| Reviews | 8 | ~250 |
| Built for Shopify | Yes | Yes |
| Price | $0 — the entire app | Free plan, then $14.99 / $29.99 / $59.99 per month |
| Offers on the free plan | Unlimited | 1 active offer |
| Quantity breaks / volume discounts | Yes, free | Yes, on the free plan |
| BOGO & Buy X Get Y | Yes, free | Professional plan ($29.99/mo) |
| Mix & match bundles | Yes, free | Professional plan ($29.99/mo) |
| Build Your Own Box | Yes, free | Multi-product bundles on Advanced ($59.99/mo) |
| Free gifts | Yes, free | Yes |
| Subscription pricing | Yes | Not listed |
| A/B testing | Yes, free | Basic plan ($14.99/mo) |
| Post-purchase & checkout upsells | Not listed | Professional / Advanced |
| B2B & wholesale pricing | Not the focus | Yes |
| Shopify POS | Not listed | Yes |
| AI translation | No | Advanced plan ($59.99/mo) |
| Trial on paid plans | Not applicable — nothing is paid | 3-day free trial |
Ratings, review counts and prices are taken from each app's public Shopify App Store listing as of July 2026 and can change — check both listings before you decide. "Not listed" means we could not confirm the feature on the public listing, not a confirmed no.
What each app actually costs
Oxify pricing:
- $0/month for everything. There is no paid tier at all.
- Unlimited offers, with no revenue cap and no order cap.
- Every feature unlocked, including BOGO, bundles, Build Your Own Box and A/B testing.
- No credit card at install and nothing to cancel later.
P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts pricing:
- Free: 1 active offer, volume discounts, basic layout, 24/7 chat.
- Basic — $14.99/mo: 5 active offers, 10+ discount types, A/B testing.
- Professional — $29.99/mo: unlimited offers, BOGO and bundles, import/export, post-purchase upsells.
- Advanced — $59.99/mo: multi-product bundles, checkout upsells, AI translation, technical support.
The practical difference shows up the moment you want quantity breaks on more than one product. On Oxify that costs nothing. On P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts it means moving to the Basic plan, and adding BOGO or bundles on top means Professional at $29.99/month — around $360 a year for feature set that Oxify includes free.
For how to actually structure your tiers once you have picked an app, see the quantity break pricing guide.
Which one should you install?
Choose P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts when:
- You sell B2B or wholesale. Pareto's app covers customer-segment and wholesale pricing properly; Oxify is built for DTC average order value.
- You want post-purchase or checkout upsells in the same app as your quantity breaks.
- You use Shopify POS and need offers to work in retail.
- Review history is your deciding factor. ~250 reviews is a much longer track record than 8, and that is a legitimate reason to prefer it.
- You need AI translation for multi-language storefronts.
Choose Oxify when:
- You want more than one offer without paying. The free plan on P: stops at a single active offer; Oxify's is unlimited.
- You want BOGO, mix & match and Build Your Own Box included. Those sit on $29.99–$59.99/month tiers with P:.
- Budget is genuinely tight. Oxify costs nothing at any store size, so there is no payback period to calculate.
- You want to test quantity breaks with no commitment before deciding whether to pay for anything at all.
A reasonable approach: install Oxify free, run quantity breaks for a few weeks and see whether tiered pricing moves your AOV at all. If it does and you later need B2B pricing or checkout upsells, you will have real data to justify paying for them. If it does not, you have spent nothing finding out.
Comparing more options? See Oxify vs Kaching Bundles, Oxify vs Pareto, or the roundup of the best quantity break apps for Shopify.
Oxify vs P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts — quick answers
Which is cheaper, Oxify or P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts?
Oxify. It is completely free — $0/month for the entire app, every feature unlocked, unlimited offers. P: has a free plan limited to 1 active offer, with paid plans at $14.99, $29.99 and $59.99/mo.
Is the P: Quantity Breaks free plan enough?
It allows 1 active offer with volume discounts and a basic layout. That works for testing quantity breaks on one hero product, but running tiers across several products needs the Basic plan at $14.99/mo or higher.
Which app has more reviews?
P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts, with roughly 250 reviews at 4.9 stars versus Oxify's 8 at 4.9 stars. Oxify is newer, so if a long review history is your main criterion, Pareto's app leads there. Both are Built for Shopify certified.
Do both apps support BOGO and bundles?
Both do, at different prices. Oxify includes BOGO, mix-and-match, Build Your Own Box and free gifts in the free app. With P:, BOGO and bundles sit on the Professional plan at $29.99/mo.
Can I run both apps at once?
It is not recommended. Two apps applying discounts to the same products can conflict at checkout and produce discounts neither app intended. Test one at a time on the same products.
Does either app need theme code edits?
No. Both install in one click and place their widgets through the Shopify theme editor on Online Store 2.0 themes, with no theme file editing.
Try Oxify free on your Shopify store today.
Quantity breaks, BOGO, mix-and-match, Build Your Own Box, free gifts, subscriptions and analytics in one app. All of it free, with no offer limit and no revenue cap.
Want to weigh the alternative too? See the P: Quantity Breaks & Discounts listing. Comparing more apps? Read Oxify vs Kaching or the best quantity break apps for Shopify.